Ask a director what protects them if a board decision is ever challenged, and you’ll usually hear some combination of three answers: the D&O policy, the company’s minutes, and “I acted in good faith.”

All three are real. All three have the same quiet weakness: none of them provides evidence that you control and demonstrate how you actually conducted yourself.

The duty is personal. The paper trail isn’t.

Whatever your jurisdiction, the shape of the duty is strikingly consistent. In the UK, section 174 of the Companies Act 2006 requires a director to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence. In the US, the duty of care — and the business judgment protection that shields directors who take informed, disinterested, good-faith decisions. Across the EU, national company laws impose their own formulations of a director’s duty of diligence, and Brazil’s corporate law does the same with unusual clarity, even rewarding directors who formally record their dissent.

Notice what every formulation has in common: it judges the process, not the outcome. Reasonable decisions go wrong every day; that’s what business risk means. What courts, regulators, and D&O insurers examine, years later, is whether this particular director was informed, asked the hard questions, weighed the alternatives, and declared their conflicts.

Examine — based on what evidence?

Three problems with the minutes

The company’s minutes are the default answer, and they fail the individual director in three ways.

They are sanitized by design. Minutes exist to record decisions, not debates. In many boardrooms, good practice is to keep minutes deliberately concise — which means the probing questions you asked before the vote may appear nowhere at all.

They belong to the company. The moment your interests and the company’s diverge — precisely the scenario in which personal liability gets litigated — the central document of the story is controlled by the other side of the table. Minutes are written by the company secretary, reviewed by management, and approved by the board as a body. They were never designed to establish what you, individually, knew, asked, and advised.

And you lose them. When your mandate ends, access to the portal, the packs, and the minute book ends with it. Your exposure doesn’t — limitation periods run for years after the decisions they concern.

Memory is not a record

Here’s the uncomfortable arithmetic. A contested decision typically comes under scrutiny two to seven years after it was taken. A portfolio director sitting on four boards attends perhaps forty board meetings a year. By the time someone asks “what exactly did you know in March three years ago, and what did you do about it?” — memory has nothing to offer that an opposing lawyer can’t dismantle.

Contemporaneous records are a different category of evidence entirely. Written on the day, dated, consistent, kept in the ordinary course — they carry a credibility that reconstruction never will. Experienced directors have always known this; it’s why the private boardroom notebook is a tradition as old as boards themselves.

The notebook’s problem isn’t the idea. It’s the execution: no structure, no reliable timestamps, no integrity guarantees, pages that can be questioned precisely because nothing proves they weren’t written last week.

What a defensible personal record looks like

Four properties separate a defensible record from a pile of notes.

Contemporaneous — written within days of the meeting, not reconstructed. Structured — decisions, questions asked, materials received (and when), dissents, conflicts declared: organized the way a lawyer would want to find them. Integral — append-only: corrections are added, never silently overwritten, so the record’s own history is clean. Portable and private — in your possession, independent of the company’s systems, surviving every rotation.

The habit costs minutes per meeting: log what you received and when; note your questions before the meeting; say the material ones aloud and ask for the substantive ones to be minuted; dissent explicitly when you dissent; and within 48 hours, write your own account of what was decided and what you relied on.

None of this is disloyalty to the companies you serve. A director’s personal record documents the director’s own conduct — it’s professional hygiene, recommended by governance institutes in multiple jurisdictions, and it makes you a better board member: the discipline of recording your questions sharpens them.

Paper solves most of this, as it has for a century. What software changes is friction and integrity — structure, trustworthy timestamps, append-only corrections, and a record that leaves with you. That’s the problem I’m building Board Companion around: the private, portable, defensible record for the individual director.

But the tool matters less than the habit. And the habit starts at your next meeting, not your next mandate.

I’ve distilled this discipline into a free, practical checklist — from reading the D&O policy before you accept a seat to securing your record before your access ends: join the waitlist and I’ll send it to you. And if you sit on boards and this touches a nerve, I’d value the conversation.

Disclaimer: This article is general good practice, not legal advice.

#corporategovernance #boardofdirectors #NED #governance #fiduciaryduty

1. The USD1MM Save Revisited – framing as an ROI event.

2. Define ROI Dimensions (Financial, Strategic, Operational, Signaling, Learning).

3. Evidence Table (BDC sales/productivity uplift; Boardstream case ROI metrics; HubSpot benefits; Visible.vc comp vs outcomes).

4. Simple ROI Models (Equity preserved, Revenue acceleration, Risk avoided).

5. Tracking System (Adv…

Read more

1. Opening Anecdote (anonymized) – The USD1MM saved.

2. Defining "Cost of Not" – 7 cost buckets: valuation leakage; wasted cycle time; avoidable dilution; credibility gap with investors; strategic blind spots; hiring & partnership delays; founder burnout/decision fatigue.

3. Evidence Snapshot – BDC & HubSpot findings; Boardstream case hints; Visible.vc comp…

Read more

Startups thrive on smart decision-making, industry connections, and strategic execution. While many founders recognize the importance of an advisory board, few know how to find and approach the right advisors—especially when they are still relatively unknown in the startup world.

An effective …

Read more

Read more

This is a conversation space exclusively for subscribers—kind of like a group chat or live hangout. I’ll post questions and updates that come my way, and you can jump into the discussion.

Join chat

Read more

In the relentless pursuit of unrivaled corporate triumph nowadays, strategic planning and open innovation have become the critical pillars of Power Moves. And when these two formidable forces unite, remarkable things happen.

Brace yourself for a mind-boggling exploration of explosive partnerships that can transform the co…

Read more

We decided to write this special series of 3 blog posts, in which we will be delving deep into the world of venture capital, exploring its dynamics, trends, and the emergence of new venture capital firms and managers. This three-part series is designed to provide a comprehensive understanding of the venture capital market,…

Read more

We decided to write this special series of 3 blog posts, in which we will be delving deep into the world of venture capital, exploring its dynamics, trends, and the emergence of new venture capital firms and managers. This three-part series is designed to provide a comprehensive understanding of the venture capital mark…

Read more

We decided to write this special series of 3 blog posts, in which we will be delving deep into the world of venture capital, exploring its dynamics, trends, and the emergence of new venture capital firms and managers. This three-part series is designed to provide a comprehensive understanding of the venture capital mark…

Read more

In today’s rapidly changing business environment, it is more important than ever for companies to be innovative. One way to do this is to adopt an open innovation approach. Open innovation is a strategic approach that involves collaborating with external partners, such as startups, universities, and research …

Read more

In the ever-changing landscape of business and economics, there is a growing focus on the concept of “open innovation.” This approach promotes collaboration and idea-sharing outside traditional company boundaries, which can result in transformative change.

But what does this mean for businesses looking to stay ahead of the game? How exactly can open inno…

Read more

Blitzscaling is a methodology that can not only help s…

Read more

That's where corporate venture capital (CVC) comes in. It is not just an option but necessary for businesses looking to diversify their portfolios and cap…

Read more

As the world of finance and investment continues to evolve, entrepreneurs and startups frequently face the challenge of raising capital to support their innovative ideas. Traditionally, venture capital has been a standard funding option for many budding businesses, but in recent years, a newer player has emerged — corpo…

Read more

Corporate Venture Building versus Corporate Venture Capital

In recent years, corporate venturing has become a popular approach for corporates to leverage innovation and create new business opportunities. Corporate venturing can be executed through two main strategies: Corporate Venture Building (CVB) and Corporate Ventu…

Read more

Introduction

Innovation is crucial for any business that wants to remain competitive in the market. Many corporations have turned to open innovation to stay ahead of the game. Open innovation is a collaborative approach that involves seeking external ideas, technologies, and expertise to advance a company’s internal inn…

Read more

In today's fast-evolving technological landscape, Corporate Venture Building (CVB) is becoming an increasingly important strategy for corporates to drive innovation and stay competitive in their respective markets. CVB is an approach that leverages the resources of the corporate parent to establish a venture ca…

Read more

Unicorns before COVID-19
Unicorns have been a hot topic in the business worl…

Read more

Latin America has been experiencing a corporate venture capital (CVC) boom in recent years. This is primarily due to the increasing interest of corporates in startups and their innovative products and services. In addition, the rise of open innovation approaches has allowed corporates to connect with startups in new and more effective ways. As a result,…

Read more